Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Literary Embarrassments: 8 Books the Authors Wish They Had Never Written


It’s a tragedy that throughout history, some authors have deemed their work so horrible that they saw fit to obliterate it. Evelyn Waugh, George Gissing and Nikolai Gogol are just some of the notable writers who have torched their own works. Without the books around to judge, we’ll never know if Gogol’s second and third installments of Dead Souls were any good, or if they instead amounted to the literary equivalent of, say, Dead Souls II: The Legend of Curly’s Gold followed by Dead Souls 3-D. 

The bigger tragedy, though, at least for the authors, is writing something terrible and not burning it. The following works run the gamut in quality, but what they do have in common is the shame of their authors.

Check out these 8 cases of writer’s regret:


1. Neil Gaiman’s Duran Duran biography 

If you click the link, get ready for some sticker shock.



Gaiman may have won a Hugo, a Nebula, a Newbery Award, and a Carnegie medal, but alas, there’s no prestigious prize for 80s pop band fan bios. Duran Duran: The First Four Years of the Fab Five (1984) was the first book Gaiman ever wrote, and he refers to it as his “dark secret.” After the copyright lapsed and reverted back to the author, the publishers wanted to bring out a new printing. Gaiman was thrilled to be able to say “No, thank you.”



2. Martin Amis’ video game guide

With a surprise guest appearance by Christopher Hitchens.



Martin Amis, the Booker Prize short-lister, son of the more famous Kingsley, and world’s oldest enfant terrible, wrote a guide to video games in 1982. Perhaps unsurprisingly, he’s avoided talking about it ever since. What is most surprising about Invasion of the Space Invaders, besides its entire existence, is that it’s written in much the same style he uses in his fiction.

Writing on Pac-Man, Amis says, “Do I take risks in order to gobble up the fruit symbol in the middle of the screen? I do not, and neither should you. Like the fat and harmless saucer in Missile Command (q.v.), the fruit symbol is there simply to tempt you into hubristic sorties. Bag it.”

Also: “PacMan player, be not proud, nor too macho, and you will prosper on the dotted screen.” The Millions writer Mark O’ Connell says, “I’m no expert, I’ll admit, but I’ll go out on a critical limb here and suggest that this might be the sole instance of the use of the mock-heroic tone in a video game player’s guide.”

Amis writes in the introduction about his first encounter with a video game machine, while hanging out with a “hard-drinking journalist” pal in Paris, circa 1980. The friend in question is believed to be Christopher Hitchens, in what is surely his one and only video game guide appearance.



3. Harlan Ellison’s Doomsman

You've got a better chance of getting this book signed by Lee Hoffman (and she died in 2007).




In a career spanning five decades and over seventy books, it stands to reason that some of Ellison’s work is going to be better than others, but Doomsman is pretty much unanimously thought of as terrible. (Typical GoodReads review: “dreadful, overwrought and sloppily written.”) In fact, a mere four pages after a character’s eyes are poked out in a torture session, Ellison writes that “he looked up.”

Ellison himself hates the book, especially as he says it was “radically altered” by editors. While it’s not impossible to find, it’s reportedly impossible to get signed. Several fans have claimed that, upon being presented with Doomsman, Ellison will tear it up on sight. Some say he’ll pay you for it first, and at least one reader says he tore the Doomsman half of the double novel away and signed just the half with Lee Hoffman’s Telepower. Ellison discarded his own half.



4. Ian Fleming’s The Spy Who Loved Me 

A departure for Fleming, it's some fans' favorite Bond novel.



If you’ve ever wondered why the movie version of this Bond novel is not just somewhat different from the book, but actually has nothing in common with it whatsoever, it’s because Ian Fleming wouldn’t allow it to be filmed. He sold the rights to the title only, after the book proved to be sort of a bomb. He refused a paperback reprint of the book in the UK, effectively trying to bury it completely.

What’s wrong with it? To start with, a lot of Bond fans don’t like that he doesn’t even show up until about ⅔ of the way through the novel, which is told from the point of view of a young Canadian woman. Critics fell over themselves to pan it. “His ability to invent a plot has deserted him almost entirely,” wrote the Glasgow Herald. The Observer went one better: “I hope this doesn't spell the total eclipse of Bond in a blaze of cornography.”



5. Dan Brown’s 187 Men to Avoid and The Bald Book

A whole penny on Amazon, if you dare.
Inane Dan Brown completists have actually driven up the price of The Bald Book.




Dan Brown may have sold 100 gazillion books, but the critics have never liked him (The Washington Post: “His novels are like high-stakes, 500-page Mad Libs”). As a result, Brown spends a lot of time defending his writing. He doesn’t do much defending of his earliest work, though: he pretends it doesn’t exist. You won’t find 187 Men to Avoid: A Survival Guide for the Romantically Frustrated Woman listed on Brown’s website. Written under a feminized version of his own name (Danielle Brown), the novelty book is a slapdash and not-very-funny list of types of men women should avoid, e.g. those who “think farting is cute.”

Soon after finishing Digital Fortress, Brown released another novelty book, this one a collection of bald jokes older than your grandfather (“you’ll never worry about going gray”). While his wife is credited as the author this time, Brown’s literary agent says that it was Brown who did the writing. Perhaps needless to say, The Bald Book is also absent from Dan Brown’s author website.




6. Louis L’Amour’s Hopalong Cassidy novels

L'Amour's denial of writing this series seems rather sad. Read his son's story for a better understanding.



Icon of the western genre Louis L’amour wrote some Hopalong Cassidy TV/movie tie-ins under the name Tex Burns in the early ‘50s. They were very much work-for-hire, over which he had little control, and the end result shamed him so much, he denied writing them for the rest of his life—and for decades, wouldn’t even admit it to his family:

“When asked, he told people that he had never written about Hopalong Cassidy, that he had never written as Tex Burns. At autograph sessions he would refuse to sign the Hopalong books that fans would occasionally bring. And for years he worried that these books which he tried so hard to ignore would be reprinted and brought back into circulation.”

L’Amour’s son has written about his father’s uncomfortable relationship with Hopalong in more detail here.



7. Neal Stephenson’s The Big U

Stephenson's reluctant re-release has cover art more befitting a serious author. This is not it.



Sci-fi writer Neal Stephenson’s first novel was a satire of college life that he himself admits was pretty terrible: “The Big U is what it is: a first novel written in a hurry by a young man a long time ago.” After the later success of Snow Crash, The Big U (which was scarce because no one had bought it in the first place) started commanding outrageous prices on eBay. Stephenson then begrudgingly allowed its reprinting, believing the only thing worse than the book itself was people paying $500 to read it.


8. Philip Pullman’s first novel

Shhhhhhhhh.



Pullman’s fantasy trilogy His Dark Materials is plenty acclaimed, earning him the Carnegie Medal and the Guardian Prize, among other accolades. His first book, though, written in 1972, is one he “adamantly” refuses to talk about, according to his fansite. In fact, he refuses to even name it, perhaps in the hopes that no one will ever find it. (The book in question is The Haunted Storm, but don’t tell Pullman you heard it here.)

Do any of your favorite authors have early titles that they ought to regret? Do you think the above writers are silly for trying to disown their works, or would you do the same?

47 comments:

  1. Ellison himself will tell you about how he offers to pay anyone who presents the double-novel for the privilege of destroying yet another copy. And how much he likes Lee Hoffman's novella on the flip side. See his introduction to "Soundless Evening" in AGAIN, DANGEROUS VISIONS, for example...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ellison has a similar lack of regard for the only theatrical dramatic film from one of his scripts, THE OSCAR, where the producers cut themselves in for writing (dis)credit as well (and it's based on Richard Sale's novel)...but Ellison holds himself responsible for a lot of what's worst about the script. He's written other screenplays for cinema, but none have been produced by commercial studios, at least...his teleplays are quite a different matter, and they have won him his Writer's Guild Awards.

      Delete
    2. There's another book Ellison is loath to sign, but I can't recall what it is right now. A movie tie-in of some sort, maybe?

      Delete
    3. I'm not sure which one you're thinking of...it could be THE BOOK OF ELLISON, a collection of Ellison essays, mostly, with appreciations from other writers in the front. It generated some bad blood between Ellison and publisher Andrew Porter for reasons that I don't remember if I've ever known. Not sure what movie tie-in there might likely be...in looking to see if there was some half-assed novelization of A BOY AND HIS DOG, I've come across this for the first time: Joanna Russ's review of the film. http://www.ejumpcut.org/archive/onlinessays/jc12-13folder/BoyDogRuss.html

      Delete
    4. I found what I was looking for. Ellison in his own words: "I don't sign DOOMSMAN under any circumstances. But I do offer to buy the copy from anyone who presents it for personalization. I also don't sign Star Trek adaptations of my "City on the Edge of Forever." I usually sign SEX GANG with the name on the cover, "Paul Merchant.""

      Delete
  2. Oh I don't know. Even a bad book that gets published is something that most people don't have. I wouldn't disown my bad books. Of course, I say that now having no books to my name. Maybe I'd change my tune later.

    Lee
    An A to Z Co-Host
    Tossing It Out

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have some web writing that I'm really glad is under a pseudonym.

      Delete
  3. Mike Resnick wrote a lot of quick paperbacks in his early career that he doesn't wish to admit to. He's not so crazy about a few he put his real name on, such as REDBEARD.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Really? Duran, Duran..$449...............

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'll throw in Victor Canning's The Great Affair. It appeared in 1970, just after Canning's affair with Diana Bird that led to the break up of his marriage. The story is full of symbolism: the hero has just been let out of prison. He is a de-frocked priest who falls for a wayward girl. They travel partly to escape family ties. They do lots of things which are unconventional and illegal, though morally justified by their thinking. The whole book can be read as a covert love letter to Diana and gesture of defiance towards his wife. Significantly there were no translations, though most of Canning's other post war books were translated into all the main European languages.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This sounds fascinating. I'm adding it to my to-read list.

      Delete
  6. Great stuff Kelly - thanks for that, I had no idea about the Gaiman and Amis titles! Graham Greene refused to have his second and third published novels, RUMOUR AT NIGHTFALL and THE NAME OF ACTION, republished, calling them "of a badness beyond the power of criticism properly to evoke"!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's good that he had some control over his publishing rights. Others aren't so lucky.

      Delete
  7. The one that always comes to mind is The Acrobats, Mordecai Richler's debut novel, published by André Deutsch and Putnam. The man succeeded in keeping it out of print for more than three decades. That it returned within a year of his death seems unseemly.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Love the research on this, and I am actually happy my first couple books are NOT in print. There's a reason for rejection slips!

    I would say, though, that those authors should be proud of how far they've come. That Space Invaders book sounds hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Most of the students don’t have any idea about the requirements of a best dissertation. The custom dissertation writing service guides the students to write their dissertation paper in cheapest price.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Truly, this article is really one of the very best in the history of articles. I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting.
    Assignment Help UAE

    ReplyDelete

  11. Thanks for sharing the information with us. I also bookmark your site and visit it in future for more info.
    Buy Assignment

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wonderful website, Nice regarding xbox, has lots of information in it, xbox 360 gold codes. Visit to know more

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for sharing such a informative post with us, it will beneficial for everyone, It is one of the best sites that I have visited. I am looking forward to read more blogs post from here

    assignment writing services company

    ReplyDelete
  14. The post is very informatics and the concept implemented is very interesting . please keep posting..
    make my assignment

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good efforts! It is a fantastic website for the people looking to learn something. Keep doing the good work. Writing an assignment is not something that every student likes. That’s why opting for our assignment writing service could be right choice as grades play a significant role in the academic as well as professional life.
    Buy Assignment

    ReplyDelete

  16. Couldn't be written any better. Reading this post reminds me of my old roommate! He always kept talking about this Assignment help| Need Assignment help

    ReplyDelete

  17. Get the best assignment help from MakeMyAssignments.com at affordable prices. Assignment help | Marketing assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  18. Such a nice blog and i appreciate your all efforts about your thoughts. it's really good work. well done. I would like to share something really helpful for education. Online Assignment Maker

    ReplyDelete
  19. While being unemployed, if you are experiencing financial contingencies, you can utilise short term loans to come out of it. Lenders Club brings out a nice opportunity to stabilise the financial condition with short term loans for unemployed borrowers.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Such a nice blog and i appreciate your all efforts about your thoughts. it's really good work. well done.I would like to share something really helpful for education. Mathematics Assignment Help Malaysia

    ReplyDelete
  21. The lenders are providing poor credit loans with the purpose of ensuring the financial constancy of its clients. It is this objective that makes them available for the individuals irrespective of their good or bad credit scores.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Very Informative Post, would love to read more, keep writing.
    I would like share some links, useful to students

    Assignment Help

    Essay Help

    Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  23. hi.. amazing post.. thanks for sharing such a great post.. i would like sharing something like about education:-
    math homework helper

    ReplyDelete
  24. Such a nice blog and i appreciate your all efforts about your thoughts. it's really good work. well done.I would like to share something really helpful for education.
    If you are searching help in Nursing Assignment Help so we are there to help you in assignmnet home work complete in fix time period.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Best Unsecured Loans is a one stop destination to search for safe unsecured instalment loans in the UK. If you have a share of home equity we can help you locate affordable homeowner loans without a delay.

    ReplyDelete
  26. You have made some decent points there. I checked on the web to find out more about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this site.

    loans for unemployed

    ReplyDelete
  27. At last my happiness and joy has been restored as my husband who left me for another girl has finally come back good and still lovely to me , i want to use this time to give thanks to Dr Blessing who has use his love spell and prayers to bring back my ex lover and also share little about my rough story between me and my husband and the other girls , i got married to the man i loved Sanchez June 23 2013 and we have been together ever since and we have leaved happily we both have a daughter , but this year 2017 when has traveled to new York on a business things changed even when he was away he never called to say hi to me and my daughter and this was unlikely of him because he loves our daughter to sky , so i began to suspect something wasn't right, but i waited for he to return to me in Canada so i know what the problems was, only for Sanchez to come back asking for divorce at first i thought he was joking , but with time i saw he was so serious on this , i tried to plead with he but nothing changed , i called my mom telling her about the situation and she said to pray about it , i was depressed and devastated on this issues and was praying and looking for help to stop the divorce and save my marriage, i seek help with many persons non could help , i continue with the search of help because i knew and have the feelings my man was not on his right senses because i know the man i married can never ask me for a divorce, so i kept on looking for solutions i spent almost all my savings seeking solution , until the Juliana a working told me about Dr blessing of blessingspiritualtemple@gmail.com, i never wanted to email him because many has taken money from me without giving any good result, but when he gave her words about Dr Blessing i decided to give it a trial , contacted him and told him about myself , he told me that he will have me to make my husband stop the divorce and reunite us again , that he gave me three days after which everything will be back to it normal place for good , i did some few things he said i should do as instructed , and let he do his work i was at work on the 15th of July about 10 AM when i received letter from my husband that my husband has cancelled the divorce case and same day at about 12 noon my husband wrote me a sweet text , and this was how me and my husband came back and today we are better as one family , so i want to use this means to tell to you all here contact Dr Blessing to for any kind of relationship or married problems and i let he solve it for you just as he has done for me , his contacts
    Email; blessingspiritualtemple@gmail.com
    blessingspiritualtemple@yahoo.com
    Whats,App. +1(951) 409 0694

    ReplyDelete
  28. Are you in urgent need of loans with the convenient repayment terms? Get advised by the brokers at Best Unsecured Loans on long term loans no guarantor. The loan with simple terms of repayments will help in managing the money.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Printer is not available in any other kind of printers. This is because Brother makes user friendly and highly efficient printers. But sometimes your Brother Printer shows some technical problems. And these technical problems should be solved immediately. Otherwise, they can create big issues. You can consult experts on their toll free number. You can call on phone number that provides tech support for Brother Printer.
    If you are experiencing some technical complication in your Brother Printer and want to find a solution, then you can contact a technician or expert. There are some experts who work in order to provide technical help and support to people across the world. They work for round the clock. Otherwise, you can connect with them through live chat. In live chat, you need to write the technical complication that you are experiencing in your Brother Printer. http://www.printertechnicalservice.com/Brothers.html
    http://www.printertechnicalservice.com/blog/how-to-connect-brother-printer-to-wifi.html

    ReplyDelete
  30. Best Unsecured Loans is a one stop solution for anyone who is looking for swift Installment loans UK. Whether you have good, bad or no history we can help you locate cheap loans available around you. We do not charge any upfront fee and extend complete online support to our customers.

    ReplyDelete
  31. essayroo.com scam? TopAssignmentReviews.com is the largest academic news and reviews website and rapidly growing in the US, Aus, UK and Singapore. We'll work hard to provide you original reviews & news.

    ReplyDelete
  32. To torch owned work required too much dare. Its big decision to criticise own writing work.
    StudentsAssignmentHelp.com writers have lots of experience in essay writing so the chances of any error is not even nominal. They provides best Essay Writing Service to students.

    ReplyDelete
  33. The assignment masters at SingaporeAssignmentHelp.com is offering its best assignment help services at the best prices.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Thanks Your post is very informative blog for us, we needs more post from your side so we can increase our knowledge. myassignmenthelp

    ReplyDelete
  35. Searching for an assignment helper that assists you in writing academic writing. Visit our site and get ready to get your assignment written by well-qualified assignment writers. candid photographers | Freelance jobs | freelance web designer |

    ReplyDelete
  36. Without the shabby and overpowering stench of numerous economically accessible air freshener items, reed diffusers have turned into an inexorably prominent approach to tenderly aroma and refresh indoor air. Marketing Assignment help |

    ReplyDelete