Wednesday, January 18, 2017

Jesus and Caligari: a Review of Upton Sinclair’s They Call Me Carpenter

They Call Me Carpenter by Upton Sinclair

I confess that I never knew much about Upton Sinclair beyond the fact that he wrote the meat-packing industry exposé The Jungle. It seems like a pretty big oversight on my part, considering that he wrote nearly 100 novels and also won a Pulitzer Prize—though not for The Jungle, as you'd think, but for the third novel in the Lanny Budd series (which is now out of print). I was also surprised to learn that he wrote the book on which Disney based the film The Gnome-Mobile, a childhood favorite that almost no one seems to remember (I was even accused once of inventing it). None of these facts are why I decided to read They Call Me Carpenter.

My interest originated with a reference in a book about horror film history, David Skal's The Monster Show. Skal mentions that Sinclair's They Call Me Carpenter uses a movie theater showing of The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari as a framing device. As a fan of silent film—and silent horror in particular—I knew I had to take a look.

The book begins with the main character, Billy, attending a screening of Caligari—"a futurist production, a strange, weird freak of the cinema art, supposed to be the nightmare of a madman"—in the fictitious Western City, California in 1921. The film has been recommended to him by his friend Dr. Henner.

"Being an American," Henner said, "you will find yourself asking, 'What good does such a picture do?' You will have the idea that every work of art must serve some moral purpose." After a pause, he added: "This picture could not possibly have been produced in America. For one thing, nearly all the characters are thin." He said it with the flicker of a smile--"One does not find American screen actors in that condition. Do your people care enough about the life of art to take a risk of starving for it?"

After seeing the film, Billy agrees with Henner's assessment that the film could not have been made America, as it is the product of "an old, perhaps an overripe culture"—which is not to say he didn't enjoy it. In fact, he offers several paragraphs of positive criticism, including:

“I had read many stories and seen a great many plays, in which the hero wakes up in the end, and we realize that we have been watching a dream. I remembered "Midsummer Night's Dream," and also "Looking Backward." An old, old device of art; and yet always effective, one of the most effective! But this was the first time I had ever been taken into the dreams of a lunatic. Yes, it was interesting, there was no denying it; grisly stuff, but alive, and marvelously well acted. How Edgar Allen Poe would have revelled [sic] in it!"

Conrad Veidt in the expressionist masterpiece The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.

Still musing about the film and its meaning, Billy leaves the theater and finds himself in the midst of a mob that "might have come direct from the inside of Dr. Caligari's asylum." The protesters are livid that Caligari is making money for Germany. "Ya, ya. Boo, boo!" they shout. "German propaganda! Pay your money to the Huns! For shame on you! Leave your own people to starve, and send your cash to the enemy." Billy is incredulous at their fury, knowing that there's nothing anti-American in the film, and contemplates reasoning with them, but ultimately realizes a mob can't be reasoned with. He makes his way through the throng, but not without getting a nasty cosh on the head.

L.A. Times, May 8, 1921.

The theater riot is based in part on Hollywood history. When rioters became violent outside Miller's Theater in October of 1921, the management halted their exhibition of The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari after only a few performances, replacing it with silent crime drama The Money Changers. Upton Sinclair may well have become aware of this event because of the fact that the replacement film was based on his own novel of the same name. (As a side note pertaining to my interest in lost films, no reels of The Money Changers are known to have survived.)

After the riot, Billy takes refuge in a church, and here the novel changes into something I (perhaps stupidly) did not anticipate. I'd like to point out that I read this novel in e-book format, so I didn't have cover art as a clue, nor did my edition have the subtitle "a Tale of the Second Coming." Maybe "carpenter" should have made me take notice, but it's a common enough name. Suffice it to say, I was blindsided when the novel turned into a Christian allegory—something which likely would not surprise many other readers. (Even if they don't have the advantage of the cover art or subtitle, the book is still far better known for being about Jesus than it it is for mentioning The Cabinet of Dr. Calgari).

Somewhat more obvious covers for They Call Me Carpenter.

While in the church, Billy sees the stained glass representation of Christ come to life. Let's not forget that he's had a nasty wallop to the head, but other people also seem to see the man, who does indeed call himself Carpenter as it says on the wrapper. How well you like the rest of the book may have a lot to do with your relationship to religion, or how much you like rather obvious religious allegory. As the two cruise through Los Angeles (or Western City, rather) in the heyday of silent film, Carpenter gets to meet movie stars and directors, like the sultry Mary Magna—a vampy Theda Bara-ish stand-in for Mary Magdalene—and the film producer Abey Tszchniczklefritszch. He turns down a lucrative film contract, appalled at the treatment of the day laborers and the inequity of wealth. His experiences lead to trouble as he can no longer tolerate the injustices he views:

"Carpenter looked about the place, now lined pretty well with cripples and invalids. Only a couple of hours of spreading rumor had been needed to bring them forth, unholy and dreadful secrets, dragged from the dark corners and back alley- ways of these tenements. He gazed from one crooked and distorted face to another, and put his 'hand to his forehead with a gesture of despair. "No, no!" he said. "It is of no use !" He lifted his voice, calling once more to the masters of the city."You make them faster than I can heal them! You make them by machinery and he who would help them must break the machine !""

For me, the novel's saving grace (pun intended just a little) is the look at the silent movie-making machinations and how little has changed as far as exploitation, marketing, and general depravity. Occasionally there are touches of humor, but it, too, is often heavy-handed. I was a tad disappointed that there wasn't a return at the end of the book to the Caligari exhibition, which I had presumed based on the use of the term "framing device." The term was used correctly, just differently than I'd anticipated (and perhaps that was just as stupid of me as being oblivious to the subject matter, as the ending seems like I should have seen it coming).

It's also an interesting companion to The Jungle, with its obvious political agenda, especially concerning labor exploitation. (Sinclair, by the way, was surprised at the reaction to his most famous novel, which he had intended to point out the inhumane treatment of workers. Public reaction zeroed in on the unsanitary conditions in the meatpacking industry and largely ignored the labor issues. "I aimed at the public's heart," said Sinclair, "and by accident I hit it in the stomach.")

If you'd like to judge the book for yourself, it's in the public domain, so you can can score a free Kindle copy (or choose from an array of affordable used versions) at You can also download it free on Project Gutenberg, where you can opt to read it directly, if you prefer.

*Written as part of the Friday's Forgotten Books event, hosted by Patti Abbott. (Will update with link to this week's entries when the list is posted, but you can still check out past reviews.)*


  1. Thanks for this post really nice and clean. Loved it.

    never give up quotes

  2. We Are Vashikaran Specialist Baba Ji. Call Us And Ask Free Question Related To Vashikaran, Inter Caste Love Marriage, Black Magic Solutions. We Will Be Happy To Answer You. Get Solutions Of Your All Problems In 24 Hours Only. For More Information Visit Our Website www.Lovevashikaranexpert.In All Days We Are Available To Help You. Contact Us 24 X 7.
    Vashikaran Specialist
    Black Magic Specialist
    Love Marriage Specialist
    love vashikaran specialist molvi ji
    love marriage specialist baba ji
    black magic specialist baba ji
    love problem solution baba ji

  3. Wanted to take this opportunity to let you know that I read your blog posts on a regular basis. Your writing style is impressive, keep it up! replica watches india

  4. You always provide quality based posts, enjoy reading your work. replica watches india

  5. Great article. keep trying to share your thought and content with us by your blog. Admission Procedure in play school

  6. All of your posts are well written. Thank you. post free ads

  7. movies 365
    The whole movie is an unendurable combination of cliches that don't add up or become interesting at any point. The discretely repeated attempts at delivering overused social messages makes it even worse. Even those messages are shallow in content, irrelevant to the movie and extremely unoriginal just as the story itself. rampage 2018

    I hoped during the movie that it would get better at some point but it went just worse. For those who are aware of these issues this is just a pretentious attempt and for the rest they don't care or won't get that message from a movie like this one. devil's candy

    I witnessed one of the worst movies of all times. You can't blame a movie for receiving an award but this clearly shows the demise of the movie industry as such movies can be produced and nominated and awarded just because of the exploitation of the social issues, and juries getting revenge and amplify the message with their own means. watch Avengers: Infinity War free online Engineering the marketing of overrated films became the norm.Oscar winning motion pictures often became classics now they are not even worth a second view. This one doesn't even deserve to be watched.

  8. I witnessed one of the worst movies of all times. You can't blame a movie for receiving an award but this clearly shows the demise of the movie industry as such movies can be produced and nominated and awarded just because of the exploitation of the social issues, and juries getting revenge and amplify the message with their own means.

  9. I am subscribing you because I want to read more about this story. please post more story. Thanks of bunch man.

    escorts in noida

    delhi escorts
    Independent Escorts in Delhi
    Call girls in Delhi
    Delhi Russian Escorts
    Aerocity escorts
    Mahipalpur escorts
    Karol Bagh escort

  10. Come and see how THOUSAND of individuals like YOU are making a LIVING by staying home and are living their dreams TODAY.

  11. I like what you shared in the article, thank you for that, it has given me more experience. I would like to share with you some interesting things, if you have free time and want to find a tool for fun read it little family quotes Read and ponder the good quotes of life below, you will surely draw in life's own deep lessonstruyện 18+ hay nhất mọi thời đạiOr you can go and search for the most fun games to play likenhạc chuông minion. Surely what I'm introducing to you will not disappoint you. Please click and experience. Having fun.

  12. I hoped during the movie that it would get better at some point but it went just worse. For those who are aware of these issues this is just a pretentious attempt and for the rest they don't care or won't get that message from a movie like this one.

  13. Welcome to the most popular tour of north India is called Golden Triangle Tour. In which you can visit world #heritage sites of Triangular shape cities of India (Delhi, Agra, Jaipur). You can enjoy the history of monuments. #pacificindiatour #Offers ✅ Tours List - Pacific India Tour
    Golden Triangle Tour 4 Night and 5 Days
    Golden Triangle Tour with Varanasi
    Golden Triangle Tour with Ranthambore
    Golden Triangle Tour 2 Night and 3 Days
    Same Day Agra Tour By Train
    India Trip Designer

  14. They know that students struggle when it comes to writing the Physics or other subjects homework and that is only because students don’t have the relative experience needed to do their homework. Students don’t know how to write the content in a way that it can be stunning and enchanting to look at. This problem is the most common as students are only experienced with writing essays and don’t know how to even begin. Our experts are highly qualified in the said task and they have the experience required to put your homework in the most efficient way.

    Students face problems when it comes to the proofreading. They don’t know how to proofread their homework and they end up doing everything wrong. Proofreading is a long process which is to be done slowly so there are no mistakes left in the homework. The next and final step is to edit the content so there are not mistakes and any irrelevant content left in the homework. We have a separate team of experts who are only experience in proofreading and editing. They go through your homework so to correct any kind of mistake and edit it out. In the end, you are given the homework written with efficiency.

    Do you need Personal Loan?
    Business Cash Loan?
    Unsecured Loan
    Fast and Simple Loan?
    Quick Application Process?
    Approvals within 24-72 Hours?
    No Hidden Fees Loan?
    Funding in less than 1 Week?
    Get unsecured working capital?
    Contact Us At :
    Phone number :+1-724-9771-197 (Whatsapp Only)


    Commercial Loans.
    Personal Loans.
    Business Loans.
    Investments Loans.
    Development Loans.
    Acquisition Loans .
    Construction loans.
    Credit Card Clearance Loan
    Debt Consolidation Loan
    Business Loans And many More Loan Opportunity:

    Full Name:................
    Loan Amount Needed:.
    Purpose of loan:.......
    Loan Duration:..
    Marital status:....
    Home Address:..
    Mobile / Cell:....
    Monthly Income:....

    Contact Us At
    Phone number :+1-724-9771-197 (Whatsapp Only)

  16. Myself Online Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer
    From India providing their Services All around the world. I am famous as Vashikaran Specialist
    & Black Magic Specialist
    . I help million of people in Love Problem Solution
    Also. I can provide you answers for Your problems related to Astrology.
    This is Really a Good Article.


    In the rather broad sphere of love marriages, a special category is of the inter-caste love marriages, and therefore, our well-learned and a leading astrologer does generate services for resolving all sorts of problems and obstacles related with the inter-caste love marriages. Till the date of writing this informative content, numerous lovers associated with inter-caste love marriages in continents worldwide have been prospered by our guru ji of global repute. To solve readily the following obstructions connected with such love marriages, please contact our globally applauded inter-caste love marriage specialist astrologer pt. Rahul Sharma at 978-180-7471, from any place (rural or urban) of India or the entire world.

  18. Famous Astrologer in UK - Online love solutions Indian Astrologer| +91-9781807471 USA | UK

  19. Vashikaran Expert In UK
    Vashikaran Expert In Delhi
    Vashikaran Expert In Dubai
    Vashikaran Expert In USA
    Vashikaran Expert In Singapore
    Vashikaran Expert In Canada

  20. Funny Happy Birthday Meme are the best way to wish a friends and family member a funny happy birthday

  21. Goyal packers and movers in Panchkula is highly known for their professional and genuine packing and moving services. We are top leading and certified relocation services providers in Chandigarh deals all over India. To get more information, call us.

    Packers and movers in Chandigarh
    Packers and movers in Panchkula
    Packers and movers in Mohali
    Packers and movers in Zirakpur
    Packers and movers in Patiala
    Packers and movers in Ambala
    Packers and movers in Ambala cantt
    Packers and movers in Pathankot
    Packers and movers in Jalandhar
    Packers and movers in Ludhiana